Keep the common roll if both bottles meet the approved placement and handling checks using a supported setup. Order a dedicated roll if the alternate bottle needs a different label footprint, presentation or construction. Ask for bottle-handling parts and setup in both proposals. Changing the label size does not necessarily remove the need for those parts.

Two different bottle shoulders and label heights are shown above their support positions.
Check the applied label and the handling setup for both bottle references. Open at full size.

Quote the handling parts separately from the label

Have the line owner identify the supported guides, infeed, supports and orientation arrangements for each bottle. Keep these items separate from the converter’s die, construction and reel specification. Krones describes handling parts matched to the existing machine. Its documentation shows why the actual equipment and container combination belongs in the quote. Krones handling parts

Mark the actual usable area on both filled samples. Record the label’s height, width, position, leading edge and any change in the approved reading face. Reuse a roll only when the installed setup can apply it within the accepted position range for each bottle. A paper cutout placed by hand can check approximate geometry before the line trial.

ProposalAdd to the comparisonEvidence required
Alternate bottle with existing rollAny equipment parts, setup, trial and usable old stockFinished samples of both bottles with the same roll and identified setups.
Alternate bottle with dedicated rollChanged label tooling, accepted label order and any equipment parts still neededA marked roll drawing, supported line setup and accepted finished packs.
Stay with current approved bottleQuoted bottle availability, usable stock and pack scheduleCurrent purchase and line conditions as the comparison baseline.
A four-step quote comparison for bottle handling parts, label rolls, reusable stock and demand.
Compare the same packaging run when deciding whether to reuse the roll. Open at full size.

Compare the cost of finished packs over the same run plan

Ask each supplier or co-packer for its actual one-time charges, expected number of changeovers, how changeovers are charged and whether the available labels match the finish and artwork in scope. Separate labels already purchased from additional labels to be ordered. A shared roll has value when the leftover pieces are approved for the planned work. Count that stock once.

In a hypothetical sparkling-water run, an alternate bottle has a shorter body panel but uses a different guide setting. A smaller label clears the shoulder. Its quote still needs the setup for the alternate bottle. Compare that route against a paper fit and line trial of the existing label, or keep the current bottle if the package and setup comparison remains open. Use real quantities and charges when making the choice.

Lock the bottle and roll pairing

Keep the bottle item references, accepted placements, roll drawings, parts or settings and pack trial together. If the converter and co-packer quote different parts of the job, give them the same revision and demand plan. Confirm sample scope before buying production quantity.

Discuss the unresolved label requirement

Send both bottle item drawings and filled samples, the current label and roll drawing, line model and changed parts or setup, change frequency and required quantities. Review beverage label options and prepare a label specification inquiry. The contact page opens an email draft and lists email or WhatsApp for attachments. Supply, proof options, testing, pricing and timing require project confirmation.